Plastic Bag Speaker Trick: Does It Work?

can you put a plastic bag over a speaker

Plastic bags are sometimes used to cover speakers to protect them from dust, food scraps, and rain. However, doing so can negatively impact the sound quality and performance of the speakers. The thin and lightweight material of the plastic bag can cause vibrations and interfere with the speaker's function, resulting in unwanted noise. In addition, covering speakers with plastic bags can increase the risk of overheating, particularly for powered speakers with built-in fans for cooling. While plastic bags may provide temporary protection for speakers in outdoor setups, they should be used with caution to avoid potential damage.

Characteristics Values
Protection from rain Yes
Protection from dust Yes
Effect on sound quality Reduced
Vibration Yes
Overheating Possible
Damage to tweeters Possible
Safety Potential issues with overheating and damage to tweeters

shunpoly

Plastic bags can be used to protect speakers from rain and dust

However, it is important to note that plastic bags can interfere with the sound quality of speakers. Speakers cause air to vibrate, and these vibrations can cause plastic bags to flutter and make shrill noises, sometimes louder than the music itself. To avoid this, some people suggest using a sheet of paper towel or a hard plastic cover instead of a plastic bag. Others recommend treating the speaker with a hydrophobic spray, which can protect the speaker from moisture damage without interfering with sound quality.

If you do choose to use a plastic bag, it is important to ensure that it is not closed, allowing the vibrating air from inside the speaker to escape. It is also recommended to use thicker plastic bags, as these are less likely to be affected by the vibrations.

For powered speakers, it is important to be aware that the amp module needs to vent. Therefore, it is not advisable to keep these types of speakers covered for extended periods, as they may overheat.

shunpoly

Speakers make the air vibrate, and thin plastic bags will vibrate along with it

Speakers emit sound by creating vibrations in the air. These vibrations can cause thin plastic bags placed over the speaker to vibrate as well, resulting in an unpleasant fluttering noise. This interference with the speaker's sound waves can sometimes produce a noise that is more jarring than the music itself.

Plastic bags are often used to protect speakers from dust, food scraps, and moisture damage. In outdoor setups, plastic bags are particularly useful for safeguarding speakers from rain. However, it is important to be cautious when using plastic bags in this manner. The bags should not be sealed tightly around the speaker, as this can lead to an increase in reflections and potentially damage the tweeters over time.

To mitigate the issue of vibrating plastic bags, some people suggest using a sheet of paper towel or a hard plastic cover instead. Another option is to use a hydrophobic spray on the speaker or a speaker scrim, which allows for minimal airflow reduction while protecting the speaker from moisture damage.

It is worth noting that the use of plastic bags may not be necessary for all speakers. Loudspeakers, for example, do not require protection from dust, and plastic bags can be avoided by simply refraining from eating at your desk. Additionally, when using plastic bags for protection, it is important to consider the thickness of the bag. Thicker bags, such as those made of fiberglass or carbon fiber composite, may interfere less with the speaker's sound.

While plastic bags can serve a purpose in certain situations, it is crucial to be mindful of their potential impact on sound quality and to explore alternative solutions whenever possible.

shunpoly

Hard plastic covers or thicker bags are less likely to vibrate

Speakers make the air vibrate, and plastic bags are thin and lightweight, so they will be affected by those vibrations. This can result in an ear-splitting sound that is worse than the music itself.

To avoid this, you can use hard plastic covers or thicker bags, as they are less likely to vibrate. The thicker walls mean that the sound from the speakers won't have enough energy to move them. Food storage boxes are an example of this, as they come in various sizes and colours.

However, it is important to note that placing speakers inside anything will change the quality of the sound. Additionally, loudspeakers do not need to be protected from dust, so plastic bags are unnecessary unless you are eating.

Some people have suggested using multiple bags filled with different gases to reduce the size of the speaker setup. However, this is not a common practice, and it is generally recommended to avoid using plastic bags as speaker enclosures.

shunpoly

Plastic bags can be used to protect speakers during transportation

In terms of weather protection, plastic bags can be effective at preventing moisture damage to speakers during transportation to and from gigs or outdoor events. Some people recommend using large contractor trash bags or heavy-duty clear plastic to cover speakers and gear when moving them in and out of venues. This is especially useful in rainy weather, as it can protect the speakers from water damage, which can cause issues with the tweeters over time.

However, it is important to be cautious when using plastic bags with powered speakers, as the amp module needs to vent. Leaving speakers covered for extended periods can lead to overheating. Additionally, some speakers have fans on the back, which need to be uncovered for proper ventilation.

To summarise, while plastic bags can be useful for protecting speakers during transportation or storage, they should be used carefully to avoid potential issues with sound quality, ventilation, and overheating. Alternative options, such as speaker scrims treated with a hydrophobic spray, can also be considered for weather protection while minimising the impact on sound quality.

shunpoly

Plastic bags should not be used with powered speakers as they need to vent

Plastic bags are sometimes used to cover speakers to protect them from dust, food scraps, and rain. However, it is not advisable to use plastic bags with powered speakers as they can interfere with the speaker's performance and cause potential damage.

Powered speakers, such as active speakers, have internal components like amplifiers that require ventilation to prevent overheating. Covering these speakers with plastic bags can restrict airflow and cause the internal temperature to rise. This can lead to performance issues and even permanent damage to the speaker's components.

Additionally, plastic bags can interact with the vibrations produced by the speakers. The thin and lightweight material of the plastic bags can start fluttering or vibrating due to the sound waves, creating unpleasant noises that interfere with the sound quality. This issue can be mitigated by using thicker bags, but this may not always be feasible and can still affect sound transmission.

To address the issue of dust and food scraps, alternative solutions like speaker scrims treated with a hydrophobic spray can be employed. These scrims allow for minimal airflow reduction while protecting the speakers from moisture damage. For outdoor setups, large contractor trash bags or heavy-duty clear plastic sheets with proper ventilation can be used to protect speakers from rain without completely sealing them.

In summary, while plastic bags may seem like a convenient solution to protect speakers, they can cause more harm than good, especially with powered speakers that require ventilation. It is essential to consider alternative methods that provide protection without compromising the performance and integrity of the speakers.

Frequently asked questions

It is not recommended to put a plastic bag over your speaker to protect it from water damage. Plastic bags can trap moisture and cause more harm than good. A better alternative is to use a speaker scrim treated with a hydrophobic spray, which will protect your speaker from moisture without affecting sound quality or performance.

It is not advisable to put a plastic bag over your speaker for protection from dust and food scraps. Plastic bags are thin and lightweight, so they will be affected by the vibrations from the speaker, causing an ear-splitting flutter.

Yes, you can use a sheet of paper towel or a hard plastic cover instead of a plastic bag. You can also use a beach umbrella or a makeshift wall made of heavy-duty plastic and tape to protect your speaker from the elements.

Using a plastic bag to reduce the size of a speaker is not an effective method. A plastic bag does not create an enclosure, and the walls of the bag would need to be at least 1mm thick fiberglass or carbon fiber composite for it to have any impact on sound reduction.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment