Chloe Zhang
Duck hunters have debated the merits of foam-filled decoys versus plastic decoys on online forums. Some hunters opt to fill their plastic decoys with foam, citing potential benefits such as increased durability, longevity, and improved performance in the water. However, others have encountered challenges when attempting this modification, including the need for multiple holes in the decoy to prevent lopsided floating and the potential for the foam to soak up water and make the decoy heavy. Foam-filled decoys are also noted to be more expensive and time-consuming to make. Hunters with extensive collections of plastic decoys may be deterred from switching to foam-filled options due to the cost and effort involved in replacing or modifying their existing decoys.
Foam-filled vs Plastic Decoys
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Buoyancy | Foam-filled decoys are lighter and don't sink. |
| Durability | Foam-filled decoys are more durable and can withstand being shot. |
| Weight | Foam-filled decoys are heavier. |
| Cost | Foam-filled decoys are more expensive. |
| Customization | Foam-filled decoys can be made at home by pouring foam into molds. |
| Maintenance | Plastic decoys require patching and repair when damaged. |
| Aesthetics | Foam-filled decoys have a classic look, while plastic decoys offer more detailed designs. |
| Water Absorption | Foam-filled decoys can absorb water and become heavy, affecting their performance. |
| Riding in Water | Foam-filled decoys ride the waves better, especially in windy conditions. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
Foam-filled decoys are more expensive but they don't sink
Duck hunters have varying preferences when it comes to choosing decoys. Some hunters prefer plastic decoys, while others opt for foam-filled ones. While plastic decoys are more affordable, foam-filled decoys offer distinct advantages that make them a preferred choice for many hunters, despite their higher price tag.
One of the biggest advantages of foam-filled decoys is their buoyancy. Unlike plastic decoys that can sink when they are shot, foam-filled decoys are designed to stay afloat. This is because the foam used in these decoys is lighter than water, allowing the decoy to remain buoyant even if it is damaged. This feature is especially valuable for hunters who don't want to worry about their decoys sinking and potentially ruining their hunt.
Foam-filled decoys also tend to ride the water more naturally and smoothly compared to plastic decoys, which may bob like a fishing float. This natural movement in the water makes foam-filled decoys more attractive to ducks, increasing the chances of a successful hunt. Additionally, the weight of foam-filled decoys can be advantageous for hunters, especially when hunting in big water or from a boat blind.
However, it is important to note that not all foam-filled decoys are created equal. Some hunters have reported issues with certain types of foam absorbing water, causing the decoys to become heavy and potentially sink. This is often the case with open-celled foam, which is why hunters are advised to use closed-cell foam to avoid this problem. Additionally, some hunters have found that their foam-filled decoys chip easily, which can be a concern when investing in more expensive options.
While foam-filled decoys may be more expensive and require careful selection to ensure quality, their advantage of staying afloat and providing a more natural ride on the water makes them a preferred choice for many hunters. Hunters are willing to invest in these decoys to benefit from their durability and effectiveness in the long run.
Ukulele Strings: Plastic or Metal?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Plastic decoys are cheaper but they sink when shot
Plastic decoys are more affordable than foam-filled ones, but they tend to sink when they are shot, which is an inconvenience for hunters. Hunters have reported that their plastic decoys have been shot and sunk, and that they have had to repair them using various methods. Some hunters opt to fill their plastic decoys with foam to prevent them from sinking, but this can be a time-consuming process.
Foam-filled decoys are more expensive, but they are also lighter and ride the water better than plastic decoys. They are also more durable and can last for many years with proper care. When a foam-filled decoy is shot, it does not sink, which is a significant advantage for hunters.
Some hunters choose to repair their shot-up plastic decoys rather than replace them with foam-filled ones due to the cost difference. There are various methods for repairing shot-up plastic decoys, including using epoxy, glue, or paracord and heat. However, some hunters prefer to invest in foam-filled decoys to avoid the hassle of repairing shot-up decoys.
While plastic decoys are more economical, foam-filled decoys offer better performance and durability in the water. Hunters need to decide whether the cost of foam-filled decoys is worth the benefits of improved buoyancy and reduced maintenance. Ultimately, the choice between plastic and foam-filled decoys depends on individual preferences and hunting styles.
In conclusion, while plastic decoys are cheaper, they sink when shot, which can be frustrating for hunters. Foam-filled decoys, although more expensive, offer better buoyancy and durability. Hunters need to weigh the cost difference against the advantages of foam-filled decoys to make an informed decision about which type of decoy to use.
Lawn Mower Carburetors: Plastic or Metal?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Foam decoys can be made at home by pouring foam into moulds
Foam-filled decoys are preferred by hunters over plastic decoys because they are lighter, ride the waves better, and are more durable. However, they are more expensive and time-consuming to make. If you want to make foam decoys at home by pouring foam into moulds, here is a step-by-step guide:
First, you need to decide on the type of foam you want to use. You can choose between EPS (expandable polystyrene) and two-part foam. EPS is made by putting the foam beads in a form, boiling the mould, and then washing and painting the decoy. Two-part foam, on the other hand, is made by mixing two parts in a specific ratio, pouring the mixture into a mould, sealing the mould, and then curing it.
If you choose to use two-part foam, you will need to heat up the mould before pouring in the foam. This can be done with a propane torch or by warming the mould in an oven. You will also need to wax the mould with 100% carnauba wax, being careful not to over-wax.
Once your mould is ready, it's time to mix your foam. For two-part foam, you will need to mix equal parts of Part A and Part B in a mixing container. Use a high-speed drill with a mixing attachment and mix for 1-2 minutes. Note that once the two parts are mixed, you only have about 4 minutes until it starts to expand.
Now it's time to pour the foam into your mould. Clamp or bolt the top and bottom of the mould together, making sure that the vent holes are clear of obstructions. This is important because if the air is not able to escape, your decoy will not turn out and the mould could crack.
After pouring the foam, wait for it to cure. This usually takes around 10-25 minutes, depending on the type of foam you are using. Once the foam has cured, you can carefully remove the decoy from the mould. You may need to hit the bottom of the mould with a hammer to break any bonds.
Finally, you can trim any excess foam with a knife or sandpaper and paint your decoy. If you used two-part foam, you will also need to figure out how to get the release agent off before painting. This can be tricky, but it is a necessary step to ensure that your paint adheres properly.
Plastic Pollution: Marine Life's Deadly Threat
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Plastic decoys can be filled with foam to make them more durable
To fill a plastic decoy with foam, hunters will often drill a hole in the decoy and fill it with spray foam. It is important to use the correct type of foam, as some foams can cause the decoy to crack or split if they expand too much. Urethane foam, for example, is a good option as it is a closed-cell foam that will not absorb water. It is also important to ensure that there is adequate ventilation when using expanding foam, as the gas needs to escape. This can be done by drilling multiple holes in the bottom of the decoy.
Some hunters choose to fill their plastic decoys with foam to improve their durability and performance in the water. Foam-filled decoys are less likely to sink and ride the waves better than plastic decoys. They are also heavier and more expensive but can last for many years with proper care. However, it is worth noting that some hunters consider filling plastic decoys with foam to be more trouble than it is worth, as the added weight can be a hindrance.
Overall, filling plastic decoys with foam can be a useful way to improve their durability and performance in the water. However, it is important to use the correct type of foam and to ensure adequate ventilation during the filling process. With proper care, foam-filled plastic decoys can last for many years and provide a more natural ride in the water.
Air Fryer Plastic Smell: Why It Happens and How to Fix It
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Foam decoys are heavier and will eventually take on water
Foam-filled decoys are heavier than plastic decoys and will eventually take on water. This is a problem for hunters as heavier decoys are harder to transport and deploy, and decoys that have taken on water are more difficult to retrieve.
Some hunters have attempted to fill their plastic decoys with foam to make them more durable and give them more weight for a better "ride" in the water. However, this can be a lot of work and requires the hunter to cut a hole in the bottom of the decoy, fill it with foam, and then epoxy the bottom back on.
Additionally, not all foams are suitable for extended exposure to water. Some foams will absorb water if exposed to it for long enough, causing the decoy to become even heavier. This is true even for closed-cell foams, which are designed to resist water absorption.
One hunter reported that they had tried every kind of spray foam sold at Home Depot and Lowe's, and all of them absorbed water and became heavy when sitting in it. Another hunter reported that their foam-filled decoys cracked and burst over the summer, which can be frustrating if the hunter has put in a lot of time and effort into creating them.
Overall, while foam-filled decoys may have some advantages over plastic decoys, their tendency to take on water and become heavier is a significant disadvantage that hunters should consider before choosing to use them.
How English Cucumbers Grow: Plastic Farming
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Foam-filled decoys are lighter, ride the water better, and are more durable than plastic decoys. They also don't sink, unlike plastic decoys.
Foam-filled decoys are more expensive and time-consuming to make. They can also be heavy and soak up water, which makes them unsuitable for walk-in hunts.
Foam-filled decoys are said to have a more classic look and ride more naturally in the water. However, they may not be as detailed as some plastic decoys on the market.
Yes, Higdon and Tanglefree are two smaller companies that make foam-filled decoys.
Yes, you can fill plastic decoys with foam to make them more durable and give them more weight for a better "ride" in the water. However, it's important to note that not all types of foam are suitable for this purpose, and some foams may cause the decoy to crack or become lopsided.
