Plastic Products: Burning Faster Than Wood?

Plastic and wood are both used as fuel sources, but which burns faster? While wood has a lower temperature of combustion than metal, some plastics burn much faster than wood. For example, unmodified polystyrene burns vigorously. In waste incineration facilities, thousands of tons of plastic burn worldwide daily, generating heat and electricity.

Some plastics burn much faster than wood, for example, unmodified polystyrene

In waste incineration facilities, thousands of tons of plastic burn worldwide daily, generating heat and electricity. Burning plastics can create the same products as fossil fuels and wood: water and carbon dioxide. However, incomplete combustion of any hydrocarbon creates noxious smoke. Therefore, it is environmentally more sound to recycle plastics than dispose of them. This approach has proven challenging and frequently results in downcycling, which requires large centralised facilities with advanced sorting lines and plastic recovery processes.

Burning plastics can create the same products as fossil fuels and wood

However, critics argue that burning plastic is not a sustainable solution to the plastic waste problem. They argue that burning plastic is a linear process, not a circular one. Plastic is made from fossil fuels, and burning it for energy does nothing to reduce demand for new plastic products or mitigate climate change. Instead, it is argued that recycling plastic waste saves more energy than burning it, as it reduces the need to extract fossil fuels and process them into new plastic.

Furthermore, waste-to-energy plants have the potential to emit low levels of toxic pollutants such as dioxins, acid gases, and heavy metals. While modern plants employ sophisticated technologies to capture these compounds, there is a risk that countries lacking environmental laws or strict enforcement may try to save money on emissions controls.

Some plastics, such as unmodified polystyrene, burn much faster than wood. However, it is important to note that the combustion of any hydrocarbon, including wood and plastic, can create noxious smoke if not burned properly.

Incomplete combustion of any hydrocarbon creates noxious smoke

Some plastics burn much faster than wood, for example, unmodified polystyrene burns vigorously. However, the speed of combustion depends on the type of plastic and the circumstances of the fire. Incomplete combustion of any hydrocarbon creates noxious smoke. This is because when there is a limited supply of air or oxygen, not everything is burned. The products of pyrolysis remain unburnt and contaminate the smoke with noxious particulate matter and gases. Partially oxidised compounds are also a concern; partial oxidation of ethanol can produce harmful acetaldehyde, and carbon can produce toxic carbon monoxide.

The designs of combustion devices can improve the quality of combustion, such as burners and internal combustion engines. Further improvements are achievable by catalytic after-burning devices (such as catalytic converters) or by the simple partial return of the exhaust gases into the combustion process.

Burning plastics can create the same products as fossil fuels and wood, such as water and carbon dioxide. However, incomplete combustion of plastics can also produce a large amount of hydrocarbons, both aliphatic (methane, ethane, ethylene, acetylene) and aromatic (benzene and its derivatives, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons). It can also result in the emission of a range of smaller oxygenated volatile organic compounds (methanol, acetic acid, hydroxy acetone, methyl acetate and ethyl formate) which are formed as combustion by-products.

In conventional terms, it is environmentally more sound to recycle plastics than dispose of them. However, this approach has so far proven quite challenging and more frequently results in 'downcycling'.

Plastic is melted, not burned, in incineration facilities

It is true that some plastics burn much faster than wood, for example, unmodified polystyrene. However, it is important to note that burning plastics is not recommended due to the harmful fumes and toxins that are emitted, such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, carbon dioxide, heavy metals, and carcinogens like dioxins and furans.

In incineration facilities, plastics are melted, not burned, through a process called pyrolysis, which shreds and melts plastics at lower temperatures and in the presence of less oxygen. This reduces the formation of toxins like dioxins and furans. Another method is gasification, which melts plastics at very high temperatures and in the near-absence of oxygen. This generates a synthetic gas that is used to fire turbines and produce electricity.

Incineration facilities have been criticised for their constant production of greenhouse gases and competition with recycling and composting facilities. However, the heat generated from burning plastics in incinerators can be converted into electricity, providing a form of energy recycling.

Overall, while some plastics may burn faster than wood, the focus is on melting plastics in incineration facilities to reduce harmful emissions and generate energy.

Wood has a lower temperature of combustion than metal

Wood will generally start to combust at around 300 degrees Celsius, although this depends on factors such as moisture content, humidity, type, and coating. A bonfire can reach temperatures as hot as 1,100 degrees Celsius, which is hot enough to melt some metals. Charcoal, which is produced when wood has released all its gases, burns at temperatures exceeding 1,100 degrees Celsius.

Wood has been used as a fuel for metal forging for thousands of years. Incomplete combustion of wood, as with any hydrocarbon, creates noxious smoke. Burning plastics can create the same products as burning wood, and thousands of tons of plastic are burned daily in waste incineration facilities.

Frequently asked questions