The Impact Of Milk Cartons: Plastic Pollution In Dairy Packaging

Plastic milk cartons are made from a combination of paper, plastic, and aluminum. Gable-top cartons, which are refrigerated, are made from 80% paper and 20% plastic. On the other hand, aseptic cartons, which are shelf-stable, contain additional layers of plastic and aluminum, with a typical composition of 74% paper, 22% plastic, and 4% aluminum. While cartons have efficient product-to-packaging ratios, reducing fuel consumption and greenhouse gas emissions, the mix of materials in cartons creates recycling challenges.

Gable-top cartons are 80% paper and 20% plastic

Gable-top cartons, also known as milk cartons, are primarily made of paper. Specifically, they are composed of 80% paper and 20% plastic. They are a form of polycoated paper packaging, designed to keep the product inside fresh by blocking out light and air that may cause spoilage. The colourful labelling on the outside is printed on the thin plastic layer.

While cartons are recyclable, they are often not accepted by municipal recycling programs due to their hybrid composition of paper and plastic. This is despite the fact that 92% of consumers surveyed by the Carton Council of North America expected their food packaging to be recycled. The United States is making progress in this area, with 61% of people surveyed in 2017 saying they recycle their food and beverage cartons, compared to 50% in 2015.

The challenge in recycling cartons lies in separating the paper and plastic components during the recycling process. However, all three materials used in cartons (paper, plastic, and aluminium) can be reused. Carton manufacturers are committed to increasing access to carton recycling and ensuring that the materials are reused. Recycling benefits manufacturers by reducing the cost of new paper and plastic purchases for future cartons.

Gable-top cartons are made from virgin materials, as recycled paper is not as strong and would need to be thicker, heavier, and more expensive to hold the same amount of liquid. Paperboard, the material used for gable-top cartons, is made from trees, a renewable resource. However, the environmental benefits end there. The process of making paper is resource-intensive, requiring significant amounts of water, fossil fuels, and chemical bleaches.

Aseptic cartons are 74% paper, 22% plastic, and 4% aluminium

Aseptic cartons are a type of packaging for food and beverage products, designed to keep the contents fresh by blocking out light and air that may cause spoilage. They are commonly used for milk, juice, soy milk, soup, broth, and wine. Aseptic cartons are also known as shelf-stable cartons, as they can be stored at room temperature.

Aseptic cartons are composed of multiple materials, primarily paper, plastic, and aluminium. Specifically, they are made up of approximately 74% paper, 22% plastic, and 4% aluminium. The paper provides stiffness and strength to the carton, while the plastic layers seal the package tightly, and the aluminium foil acts as a barrier to protect the contents from air and light.

The mix of materials in aseptic cartons creates challenges during the recycling process, as the components need to be separated. However, the high quality of the materials makes them desirable for remanufacturing into new products. All three materials used in cartons can be reused, and recycling benefits manufacturers by reducing the cost of new paper and plastic purchases.

Despite the recyclability of cartons, many municipal recycling programs do not accept plastic/paper hybrid cartons. This has led to concerns about the environmental impact of these cartons, as they may end up in landfills. However, efforts are being made to increase access to carton recycling and improve the recycling rate.

Plastic milk bottles are lightweight and energy-efficient

Plastic milk bottles have largely replaced glass bottles for home consumption. This is because plastic milk bottles are lightweight and energy-efficient, requiring less energy to ship than glass bottles. They are also more durable and have a longer shelf life than other containers.

The most common material in milk packaging is high-density polyethylene (HDPE), a type of plastic that is strong, lightweight, and relatively inexpensive. HDPE bottles typically weigh just 4 ounces per half-gallon container, which is significantly lighter than glass bottles. This makes them more energy-efficient to transport, as less fuel is required to move a lighter load. Additionally, plastic milk bottles are often blow-moulded, a process that allows for the creation of lightweight containers with minimal material usage.

The lightweight nature of plastic milk bottles also extends to their secondary packaging. Returnable plastic crates can be used to transport milk bottles, further reducing the overall weight of the shipment. This is especially beneficial when compared to the weight of glass bottles, which can constitute about one-third of the total weight of a shipment. By using plastic bottles and crates, the overall weight of the shipment is reduced, leading to increased energy efficiency.

However, it is important to consider the environmental impact of plastic milk bottles. While they are energy-efficient in terms of transportation, the production and disposal of plastic bottles can have negative consequences. Plastic pollution is a significant issue, and the recycling rate for HDPE bottles in the US is relatively low, at only 30-35%. Additionally, the manufacturing of plastic bottles can consume a significant amount of energy, particularly during the extraction of raw materials and production processes.

To mitigate the environmental impact, some strategies include improving recycling practices, using biodegradable plastics, and reducing the amount of plastic used in packaging. By implementing these strategies and continuing to explore innovative solutions, it is possible to balance the benefits of energy efficiency with the need for sustainable practices in the production and disposal of plastic milk bottles.

Plastic milk jugs are made from high-density polyethylene

HDPE is also very light, requiring less energy for shipping compared to other materials. The low weight of HDPE plastic milk jugs is advantageous for both the manufacturer and the retailer, as it reduces transportation costs. Additionally, the low melt temperature of HDPE expedites the manufacturing process, making it more cost-effective.

In the production process, HDPE pellets are mixed with recycled HDPE flakes. However, there are limits to the amount of recycled HDPE that can be included. Old milk jugs made of HDPE are not recycled into new milk jugs due to sanitary concerns. Instead, they are recycled into other products, such as composite lumber, ensuring the material is reused.

The shelf life of pasteurized milk in HDPE bottles has been determined to be between 10 and 21 days when stored at 4–8 °C. The recycling rate for HDPE bottles in the US is relatively low, with only about 30–35% being recycled. However, carton manufacturers are committed to increasing access to carton recycling and promoting the reuse of materials.

Plastic milk containers are recyclable

In contrast, aseptic or shelf-stable cartons, often used for non-refrigerated products like soup, wine, and soy milk, are made with additional layers of plastic and aluminum. These cartons can also be recycled, but their complex structure makes the recycling process more challenging. At recycling plants, the entire carton is typically turned into building materials like construction boards, rather than separating the paper, plastic, and aluminum layers.

The recyclability of plastic milk containers also depends on the type of plastic used. Most plastic milk containers are made from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or No. 2 plastic. HDPE bottles are considered recyclable, but the recycling rate in the US is only about 30-35%. It's important to check the specific guidelines provided by your local recycling collector, as guidelines can vary by location.

To improve the recyclability of plastic milk containers, it is recommended to rinse them before placing them in the recycling bin. This helps ensure that the containers can be properly recycled and reduces the risk of contamination. Additionally, keeping the containers intact, such as by screwing the cap back on, can prevent them from becoming litter during the recycling process.

Frequently asked questions