Recycling Efforts: Tracking Plastic Waste In Nuc

Plastic is everywhere, and it's cheap to make and profitable. But it's also harmful to the environment and our health. While recycling is often touted as a solution to plastic pollution, the reality is that most plastic isn't recycled. The recycling rate for plastic in the United States was only 8.7% in 2018, and an NGO report claimed that this dropped to around 5% in 2021. Globally, it's believed that just 9% of plastic is recycled, with the majority of plastic waste being incinerated, landfilled, or mismanaged. This is due to a range of factors, including the economics of recycling, the incompatibility of different plastics, and the challenges of collecting, sorting, and processing recyclable materials. Despite new technologies and initiatives, the overall picture is that plastic recycling is falling short of what's needed to address the global plastic crisis.

Plastic dishware has the lowest capture rate for recycling

It is estimated that the world produces around 350 million tonnes of plastic waste each year, with only 9% of this being recycled. Half of the world's plastic waste goes straight to landfill, and a further fifth is mismanaged, meaning it is not recycled, incinerated, or stored in sealed landfills. This plastic often ends up in rivers, lakes, and the ocean, causing significant pollution.

While public awareness and infrastructure improvements have helped increase recycling rates for some materials, plastic dishware has the lowest capture rate for recycling. In New York City, for example, a waste characterization study found that the capture rate for metal, glass, and plastic in 2023 was 40.9%, down from previous years. The same study also found that contamination rates in metal, glass, and plastic recycling had increased to 27.5% in 2023, up from 18.7% in 2017. This is due in part to the inclusion of more plastic categories as recyclable, which has led to more contamination in the recycling stream.

Plastic dishware, in particular, faces several challenges when it comes to recycling. One issue is that plastic dishware is often made from a variety of different plastics, which can be difficult to separate and process for recycling. Additionally, plastic dishware is often contaminated with food residue, which can render it unrecyclable. Many recycling facilities are not equipped to handle this type of contamination, so plastic dishware ends up being discarded or incinerated instead of being recycled.

Furthermore, the low capture rate for plastic dishware can be attributed to a lack of public awareness and understanding of how to properly recycle these items. Many people are unsure of which types of plastic dishware are recyclable and how to prepare them for recycling, such as by removing food residue. This leads to contamination in the recycling stream, as well as low participation rates in recycling programs.

To improve the capture rate for plastic dishware, it is essential to address these challenges. This includes improving recycling technologies to handle mixed plastics and contaminated materials, as well as increasing public education and awareness about proper recycling practices for plastic dishware. Additionally, implementing policies that encourage or require the use of recyclable materials in plastic dishware production can help to increase the capture rate.

Plastic film makes up 7.5% of NYC's waste stream

Plastic film, such as supermarket bags, makes up 7.5% of NYC's waste stream and is extremely challenging to recycle. In 2023, the capture rate for single-use plastics was 9.7%, while the overall contamination rate for metal, glass, and plastic was 40.9%. The contamination rate for MGP (Metal/Glass/Plastic) recycling, which includes organic material, paper, and non-recyclable film plastic, increased to 27.5% in 2023 from 18.7% in 2017.

The recycling rate for metal, glass, plastic, and paper in NYC has been declining, and contamination rates have been increasing. A 2022-2023 waste characterization study found that 75% of residential waste in NYC could be diverted from landfills, but the city's diversion rate was only 20.2%. The New York City Housing Authority, which includes 1,938 recycling bins in outdoor public areas, recycles at a rate of just 1.5%. The low recycling rate has been attributed to the need for more recycling containers in more convenient locations and the high incidence of contamination.

In 2017, the amount of non-bottle rigid plastics captured in the recycling stream was 27.5%, an increase from 16.4% in 2013. The capture rate for rigid plastic bottles and jugs was 50%, down slightly from 50.6% in 2013. The residential capture rate for paper and cardboard into the recycling stream has fluctuated over the years, reaching 51.3% in 2017 before falling to 48.8% in 2023.

While NYC has no landfills or incinerators within its boundaries, the city produces 12,000 tons of waste every day. NYC's non-recyclable waste is sent to landfills in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Virginia. Manhattan's waste is often incinerated across the Hudson River in New Jersey. The export of garbage to other communities cost New York City taxpayers $290 million in 2007, excluding collection costs. Diesel trucks carry Manhattan's garbage 7.8 million miles each year, contributing to industrial pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.

Only 8.5% of plastic refuse was recycled in 2018

Plastic recycling rates in the United States have stagnated over the past decade, with the Environmental Protection Agency estimating that only 8.5% of plastic refuse was recycled in 2018. This is indicative of a broader issue with waste management, as recycling rates for all materials in the waste stream have plateaued at around 30-35%.

The low recycling rate for plastics is particularly concerning given that plastics are a growing form of packaging. In New York City, for example, 43% of dumped or burned municipal waste consists of packaging and containers, with plastic dishware having the lowest capture rate of any recyclable material. Only 5% of plastic dishware, including single-use plastic cups, plates, and cutlery, enters the recycling stream, and much of the city's recyclable waste is sent to landfills in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Virginia.

The issue is not limited to post-consumer waste, as the production and use of plastics also contribute to environmental concerns. Lobbying by business and environmental groups has intensified around topics such as recycling goals and regulations, with industry and environmentalists recognizing the potential impact of legislation in a significant state like New York. Additionally, the management of plastic waste is costly, with the WWF calculating a global cost of $32 billion per year in 2021.

To address these challenges, some states are experimenting with new approaches. For instance, the Recycling Partnership has supported a bill proposed by Kaminsky, which calls for producers to set their own targets for the use of recyclable materials in packaging and the recycling of that packaging. While these efforts represent steps in the right direction, there is still much to be done to improve plastic recycling rates and reduce the environmental impact of plastic waste.

NYC sends non-recyclable waste to landfills in other states

New York City produces 12,000 tons of waste every day, and, as the city has no landfills or incinerators, it sends its non-recyclable waste to landfills in other states. These include Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Virginia, with much of Manhattan's waste being incinerated across the Hudson River in New Jersey.

The city has a 20-year plan to handle its waste in an environmentally and economically sustainable manner, and it is encouraging residents to reduce, reuse, recycle, and compost their waste. Despite these efforts, some sources claim that NYC recycles only one-fifth of its trash, with the rest going to landfill. Others claim that up to 80% of what is put in recycling bins ends up in landfills, as it is cheaper to produce plastic from oil than to recycle it. Additionally, China's decision to no longer purchase recycled plastic from the US has worsened the situation.

The city provides its residents with three different coloured bins: one for trash, one for recycling, and one for clean green. However, some residents have observed that recyclables are often thrown in with the regular trash and compacted, ending up in landfills. This is a significant issue, as landfills are responsible for 36% of all methane emissions in the US, contributing to global warming.

To address this, New York could consider leasing a landfill site that can accommodate a large energy co-generation (garbage-to-power) plant and a solar farm. This would allow the city to generate electricity from waste and power electric garbage trucks with no pollution. Additionally, the city could benefit from more consistent trash collection from corner waste baskets to prevent people from littering.

NYC's overall recycling rate is 17%

New York City's overall recycling rate is 17%. However, the city recycles a wide variety of waste, and the capture rate for each type of recyclable material varies widely. For example, the capture rate for green container glass, the highest of any material category, is 75%, while the capture rate for plastic dishware is only 5%. Cardboard boxes and related paper products have one of the highest capture rates of any material, with 71% entering the paper recycling stream.

The overall recycling rate in NYC is impacted by several factors. Firstly, the city has no landfills or incinerators, so non-recyclable waste is sent to landfills in other states, such as Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Virginia. Much of Manhattan's waste is incinerated across the Hudson River in New Jersey. Additionally, public awareness and participation in recycling efforts play a significant role in the recycling rate. For example, the capture rate for aluminum cans is only about 28% because they are frequently scavenged from recycling bins and remain in the refuse stream, ultimately headed for landfills.

Another factor affecting the recycling rate is the type of plastic being recycled. Plastic dishware, including single-use plastic cups, plates, and cutlery, has one of the lowest capture rates. Additionally, some types of plastic, such as plastic labeled #7, are generally not recyclable and often end up in landfills. The recycling of plastics is a complex issue, and despite three decades of recycling efforts, the amount of plastic waste in the US has not significantly decreased.

To address the low recycling rate of plastics, New York State is considering new approaches. One proposal is to charge product-makers to dispose of their packaging, encouraging the use of more easily recyclable, compostable, or reduced packaging. Another suggestion is to implement "extended producer responsibility" laws, which would require producers of consumer goods to pay for the disposal of their packages and containers. These initiatives aim to reduce plastic waste and improve the overall recycling rate in NYC.

Frequently asked questions