Brown Plastic: What's Its Recyclability?

Plastic waste is a pressing issue for environmentalists, governments, and organizations, as the majority of plastics are disposed of in non-environmentally friendly ways, leading to polluted oceans, landfills, and ecological damage. While recycling plastic is critical to improving the environment and waste management, not all types of plastic are recyclable. Intense or dark-colored plastic, such as brown plastic, is difficult, if not impossible, to recycle and reuse. This is because recycling machines used to sort plastic for processing cannot detect dark-colored plastic, including black plastic, which is considered the most difficult color to recycle.

Sorting and recycling machines cannot detect dark-coloured plastic

Plastic recycling is critical to improving the environment and bettering waste management solutions. Before being recycled, plastics are sorted according to their resin type, either manually or using mechanized automated processes, or even by colour. Sorting and recycling machines use advanced sensor technologies to analyze the colour attributes of plastic materials. However, these machines are unable to detect dark-coloured plastic.

The stream of plastic waste is initially sorted using near-infrared (NIR) sensors which identify polymer type by measuring each polymer’s unique absorption spectrum at NIR wavelengths. Once sorted into polymer types, the stream is sorted using optical sensors to separate the plastic by colour. Clear and white plastic can be recycled back into clear and white plastic, whereas coloured plastic is typically recycled into much less versatile grey-ish or black plastics.

Optical sorters can differentiate between clear, light blue, dark blue, green, and other coloured PET containers. However, they struggle to differentiate between white and clear plastic. The presence of coloured pigments in plastic recycling streams makes it harder to obtain recycled plastic with vibrant and distinct colours, and the resulting product is usually restricted to being used for grey or black products.

To address the issue of dark-coloured plastic not being detectable by sorting machines, supermarkets can switch to clear or white plastic, which is more recyclable. Alternatively, companies can use alternatives to plastic, such as paper-based packaging, which generally has a less significant negative impact on the recycling process. Methods of removing coloured inks from the surfaces of plastics to improve recyclability have been developed, but these processes do not remove the colour from the plastic itself.

The quality of recycled plastic is lower, requiring virgin plastic pellets to be added

The widespread use of plastic has led to significant environmental issues, including water pollution, global warming, resource depletion, and microplastic pollution. Recycling plastic waste is crucial to mitigate these impacts, but it is not always the most financially viable option. Recycling facilities are costly to build and operate, and small quantities of plastic can make the process uneconomical. Additionally, certain types of plastic, such as low-density polyethylene (plastic bags), can be challenging to recycle due to their tendency to tangle in machinery.

Despite these challenges, recycling plastic offers significant benefits. It reduces landfill space, conserves natural resources, and lowers energy consumption compared to producing new plastic from raw materials. However, one concern with recycled plastic is the potential decrease in quality compared to virgin plastic. Virgin plastics, or new and pristine materials, have a sturdier molecular structure, ensuring precision and high performance in manufacturing. On the other hand, recycled plastics may exhibit reduced chemical, thermal, and impact resistance due to contaminants in the recycling stream, leading to polymer degradation.

To address this quality discrepancy, strategies such as blending recycled and virgin plastic have been proposed. By adding a small percentage of virgin resin, typically around 30%, the resulting blended plastic can achieve properties nearing those of 100% virgin material. While this approach may not satisfy those advocating for a complete rejection of virgin plastic, it can significantly reduce the overall volume of virgin plastic produced. Additionally, advancements in sorting and recycling technologies are continuously improving the quality of recycled plastic, making it "as good" or "good enough" for most applications.

It is worth noting that the recyclability of plastic depends on its type and resin code. Lower resin codes generally indicate easier recyclability, with plastic types such as PET and HDPE being widely recycled. However, certain plastics, like polyvinyl chloride (plastic number 3) and bioplastics, are not recyclable through standard collection methods. Additionally, dark-colored plastics, such as black or brown plastic, pose challenges for recycling machines as they cannot detect them during the sorting process.

Metal is easier to recycle than plastic

It is important to understand the differences in recyclability between metal and plastic, as they are two of the most commonly used materials with very distinct environmental impacts. While plastic, including brown plastic, can be technically recyclable, it is a complex and often challenging process, with many types of plastic ending up in landfills or the ocean. On the other hand, metal is much easier to recycle and has a more straightforward and efficient recycling process.

One of the key advantages of metal over plastic is that it can be recycled indefinitely without a loss in quality. Metal items can be melted down and reused multiple times, which is not the case with plastic. Plastic, including brown plastic, often contains a mix of different polymers, additives, and colors, which makes it difficult to recycle effectively. The recycling process for plastic often results in a lower-quality material that can only be used for certain applications. In contrast, metal retains its properties and can be reused repeatedly without any degradation in performance.

The recycling process for metal is generally more efficient and environmentally friendly than that of plastic. Metals are often collected, sorted, and melted down in a single process, which is energy-efficient and cost-effective. Additionally, metal recycling does not typically require the use of harmful chemicals or produce toxic by-products, as is often the case with plastic recycling. The high temperatures used in metal recycling ensure that any impurities are burned off, resulting in a pure product that is ready for reuse.

Furthermore, metal is a more durable and long-lasting material than plastic, which contributes to its recyclability. Metal items are less likely to break or degrade over time, reducing the need for frequent replacement. This longevity reduces the demand for new resources and energy-intensive production processes. In contrast, plastic is more prone to breakage and degradation, often resulting in a shorter lifespan and increased waste generation.

The recyclability of metal also extends to a wider range of products and applications. Metal items such as cans, bottles, appliances, and construction materials can all be effectively recycled. The versatility of metal means that it can be reused in a variety of forms, from new cans to structural beams. In contrast, the recycling of plastic is often limited to specific types and applications, with many plastic products ending up in landfills or being incinerated due to a lack of recycling options.

Overall, metal is a more sustainable and environmentally friendly choice than plastic due to its ease of recycling. The process of recycling metal is more efficient, produces fewer harmful by-products, and results in a high-quality reusable material. Metal's durability and versatility further contribute to its recyclability, ensuring that it remains a valuable resource throughout its lifecycle. While efforts are being made to improve plastic recyclability, metal currently offers a more straightforward and eco-friendly option for consumers and industries alike.

Plastic recycling can conserve natural resources and energy

Plastic recycling is critical to improving the environment and bettering waste management solutions. It is also fundamental to the environment, offering specific benefits. Recycling plastic can conserve natural resources and energy, as well as reduce landfill waste.

Recycling plastic helps conserve natural resources in two key ways. Firstly, it reduces the need to extract and process raw materials, which can be both labour-intensive and expensive. By using recycled materials, manufacturers can create the same products with fewer resources and less energy expenditure. This is because recycled materials have already been refined and processed once, making the second manufacturing process less energy-intensive. Secondly, recycling plastic conserves natural resources because plastic is made from oil, a natural resource. Therefore, recycling plastic means less oil is needed to create new plastic products.

The process of recycling plastic also saves energy. The creation of new products from scratch requires a lot of energy to collect, move and refine the natural resources needed. Recycling plastic reduces or eliminates this energy expenditure as the recycled materials have already been processed once. For example, with the amount of energy it takes to make one new aluminium can, 20 recycled cans can be produced.

However, it is important to note that not all plastic is widely recyclable. Some plastics are incredibly hard to recycle, such as crisp packets, salad bags, and plastic wrap. Additionally, some plastic types, like low-density polyethylene (LDPE), used in plastic bags, are cheap and low-quality, making their recycling financially unviable. Furthermore, sorting plastic by colour can be challenging, as machines used to sort recycling cannot detect dark-coloured plastic, such as brown or black plastic.

Some plastics are hard to recycle due to their chemical composition

Plastic waste is a major environmental concern, as the majority of plastics are disposed of in ways that result in polluted oceans, landfills, and ecological damage. Therefore, recycling plastic is critical to improving the environment and waste management solutions. However, not all plastics are widely recyclable, and some are harder to recycle due to their chemical composition.

The recyclability of plastic types depends on how they are made. Thermoset plastics, for example, contain polymers that form irreversible chemical bonds, making them challenging to recycle. These plastics are used in products such as bakelite, melamine, and epoxy resins found in wind turbine blades. On the other hand, thermoplastics can be re-melted and re-molded, making them more suitable for recycling.

Another factor that affects recyclability is contamination. Many plastic products, such as food packaging and bottles of motor oil, are contaminated with oil and grease, making them difficult to recycle through mechanical recycling processes. Mechanical recycling involves grinding and melting plastic waste to create new products, but contamination can result in lower-quality recycled materials.

To address the limitations of mechanical recycling, chemical recycling, or advanced recycling, has emerged as a complementary solution. Chemical recycling breaks down plastic waste into monomers or molecules, allowing for the removal of contaminants and the creation of valuable new products. This process can handle materials with multiple layers of different polymers, making it suitable for recycling flexible food packaging and multi-layer plastics.

While chemical recycling offers promising solutions, it is important to note that not all plastic waste can be recycled using this method. Additionally, the development and implementation of chemical recycling technologies may require supportive policy frameworks and further research into enzymes and catalysts that can aid in the process.

Frequently asked questions