China's Film Plastic Recycling Efforts: Effective?

China's waste import ban, instated at the end of 2017, prevented foreign inflows of waste products, including plastics. This ban has had a significant impact on the global recycling industry as China was the world's largest importer of waste plastics, processing hard-to-recycle plastics for other countries. The documentary film 'Plastic China' explores the human impact of this waste trade, following the lives of two families who recycle plastic waste, highlighting the social and environmental consequences of the global trade in recyclables. With China's ban on foreign waste, the film gained prominence, and it has been argued that it played a role in shaping the recent evolution of the recyclable waste trade. China is now focusing on boosting its domestic recycling and incineration capabilities and promoting green plastic products to address plastic pollution.

Plastic China documentary

The documentary 'Plastic China' was directed by Jiu-Liang Wang and premiered at the International Documentary Film Festival Amsterdam in November 2016. It was also shown at the 2017 Sundance Film Festival. The film is an observational documentary about a recycling workshop in China that processes plastic waste from other countries. The 80-minute-long feature follows the lives of two families who make their living by recycling plastic waste, centering on 11-year-old Yi-Jie, who has to work in the factory and care for her younger siblings instead of going to school. The film captures the unsafe and unhealthy conditions in which adults and children toil, exposing the disparity between Western lifestyles of consumption and those who deal with the concomitant waste.

The documentary highlights the social inequality and hierarchical structure of facility owners and the workers they employ for low compensation. The families in the film live among mountains of plastic, sorting and recycling waste from Europe, the United States, and other parts of Asia. Despite the harsh conditions and the stench from incinerators, the children in the film find moments of joy, such as discovering balloons or magazines that give them a glimpse of a different, richer life. The images in the film tell a universal story of social inequality and the impact of global consumerism on the recycling industry.

'Plastic China' is a follow-up to director Jiu-Liang Wang's debut documentary, 'Beijing Besieged by Waste' (2011), which also explored themes of waste and recycling in China. The film has received positive reviews, with some calling it an "eye-opener" and praising its ability to highlight the gulf between the haves and have-nots in modern-day China. It has also been described as a "milestone" by Ma Jun, the director of the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs.

The official site for the documentary film 'Plastic China' mentions that Ruby Chen is the co-founder and CEO of the non-profit CNEX Foundation Limited. She has been the executive producer for almost 80 documentaries, including award-winning films such as '1428', 'KL: Life and Music', and 'Mothers'. Benjamin Guanting Yue started filmmaking as a director and producer in 2006 and founded Beijing TYC Media to support independent films in China. He began working on 'Plastic China' with the director in 2010.

China's waste import ban

The decision to impose the ban was driven by environmental and health considerations. China, as the largest importer and producer of plastics, had been grappling with plastic pollution for decades. The country's rapid economic development and rise in living standards in the 1990s increased its demand for plastic products by 21% annually. However, the lack of raw materials and inefficient recycling systems led to a decline in the recycling rate, with about 60% of plastic waste being discarded or not recycled. This resulted in blockages in urban drainage systems and contributed to air and water pollution, endangering the health and lives of people.

The documentary "Plastic China" shed light on the social and environmental impact of the global trade in recyclables, particularly the hazardous working conditions and the human cost of waste management in China. The film gained prominence after the Chinese government's announcement of the waste import ban in July 2017, contributing to the growing awareness of the issues surrounding waste exports.

The ban has had significant repercussions on a global scale, disrupting recycling industries and forcing countries highly dependent on China for waste management to seek alternative solutions. It is predicted that by 2030, with the implementation of the ban, 111 million metric tons of plastic waste will be left unaccounted for. However, in the short term, the ban has shown positive signs of improving environmental impact indicators, despite contributing to global warming.

To address the challenges posed by the ban, China launched a five-year action plan in 2021 to phase out single-use plastics, promote alternatives, and boost recycling. The country also stopped issuing import licenses for overseas waste, further tightening the restrictions on waste imports. These measures are expected to have a positive impact on China's environmental sustainability in the long run, reducing carbon emissions and mitigating the plastic waste trade flow worldwide.

Recycling standards and waste disposal

China has historically been the world's largest importer of waste plastics, receiving ten million tons per year from most developed countries. However, China's waste import ban, which came into effect in 2018, has prevented the inflow of foreign waste products, including plastics with a contamination level above 0.05%. This ban has significantly impacted the global recycling industry, as China was the primary processor of hard-to-recycle plastics for other nations.

The documentary film "Plastic China" shed light on the social and environmental issues surrounding China's waste imports. It depicted the lives of former peasants who recycled plastic waste, highlighting their poor living and working conditions. The film gained prominence and contributed to the public discourse on waste exports to China, ultimately influencing the country's decision to ban "foreign waste."

China's ban on waste imports aims to address the environmental and health issues associated with inappropriate waste disposal methods, such as landfills and incinerators. The burning of uncategorized waste releases toxic air pollutants and contributes to carbon dioxide emissions. However, the ban has also disrupted the supply and demand balance for recycled commodities and affected the recycling industry in other countries, particularly in North America.

To address the challenges posed by the ban, the National Waste & Recycling Association (NWRA) has urged the Chinese government to phase in its new stringent standards gradually. They recommend adopting internationally recognized standards and enforcing reasonable standards on high-quality materials. Additionally, the NWRA supports China's efforts to improve environmental protection and enhance its recycling infrastructure.

China is also exploring innovative technologies for waste disposal, such as pyrolysis plants. These plants can recycle challenging materials that normal recyclers cannot and produce minimal carbon dioxide emissions without contamination. However, the economic profitability of these plants will determine their future expansion.

Labour exploitation

The 2016 documentary film 'Plastic China' by Wang Jiuliang offers a critique of the plastic waste industry and the social issues arising from it, including labour exploitation. The film highlights the stark contrast between modernity and agricultural life, depicting how waste from developed countries is shipped to a small agricultural village in China.

The film centres around an 11-year-old girl, Yi-Jie, who lives and works with her family in a plastic waste recycling workshop. The family, belonging to the Yi minority group, is originally from a mountain village. Yi-Jie longs to go to school, but instead, she works in the workshop, sorting and processing waste.

The film portrays the harsh reality of the recycling industry, where workers like Yi-Jie and her family engage in manual labour, handling waste with their bare hands. This work takes a toll on their physical and mental health, exposing them to toxic environments and irreversible damage. The prosperity of these recycling hubs relies on migrant workers, who often have little bargaining power regarding their working conditions.

Kun, the owner of the workshop in the film, represents the educated and powerful class. He depends on the workers to perform the labour that others refuse, yet he looks down on them. Kun himself works tirelessly to achieve social status and provide a better life for his family, neglecting his and his family's health in the process.

The film highlights the global chain of exploitation within the recycling and consumerist culture. It reveals how the plastic waste industry preys on vulnerable workers, who labour in unsafe conditions for meagre wages, while the environmental and health consequences impact those living in and outside of China.

Plastic pollution

The documentary "Plastic China" shed light on the social and environmental impact of the global trade in recyclables, particularly waste plastics. The film highlighted the working and living conditions of families involved in plastic recycling, drawing attention to the human cost of improper waste management. "Plastic China" gained prominence and influenced public discourse on waste exports, ultimately contributing to the conversation on plastic pollution.

China's waste import ban, instated in 2018, was a significant development in the country's efforts to combat plastic pollution. The ban targeted various types of waste, including plastics with contamination levels above 0.05 percent. This decision had global repercussions, as China had been processing hard-to-recycle plastics for other countries, especially in the West. The ban prompted a shift in focus towards improving domestic recycling capabilities and addressing the overuse of plastic in packaging and agriculture.

Despite the ban, plastic pollution remains a challenge in China. The country produces over 60 million tonnes of plastic annually, yet its recycling rate is only around 30%. To tackle this issue, China has encouraged major cities to implement trash sorting policies, build industrial-scale recycling plants, and ban single-use plastic items. These initiatives aim to reduce plastic waste and improve recycling infrastructure.

Additionally, China is exploring innovative technologies, such as pyrolysis plants, to enhance its waste disposal capabilities. Pyrolysis involves melting plastics at high temperatures to produce smaller hydrocarbons that can be refined into diesel or other petrochemical products, including new plastics. This technology offers a more environmentally friendly approach to waste disposal, producing minimal carbon dioxide and no contamination. However, the economic profitability of these plants will determine their future expansion.

In conclusion, China's efforts to combat plastic pollution involve a combination of policy changes, increased domestic recycling, and the exploration of innovative waste disposal technologies. While challenges remain, the country is taking significant steps to address the issue of plastic pollution and promote environmental sustainability.

Frequently asked questions